The Best Crib Mattresses Reviewed By Disruptive Women

If you love your newborn baby and would like to make it comfortable, there is no doubt that you cold like to give the best things to it. A crib mattress without any doubt is a wonderful one of the most important things for your baby. Hence it is quite natural for you to find out ways and means by which you would like to lookout for the best crib mattress. But making the right choice without any doubt is a tough job because of various reasons. First and foremost, many of us do not have much knowledge about these mattresses and therefore do not know where to start and where to end.

Mattresses Are As Important As Cribs

Choosing then could often be a confusing and boring task but it cannot be done in a burry. Each and every step has to be planned carefully and there are many considerations which must be taken into account. Often many of us pay more attention to the crib instead of the mattress. This is not desirable because mattresses are as important as cribs Therefore we must spend time and effort and buy the next one possible. This is because babies will be spending quite a bit of time in the cribs. Newborn babies often sleep up to 18 hours a day and therefore you must be sure that it has the best place to sleep. Towards this objective, there is hardly any doubt that cribs have a big role to play.

Things That You Should Consider

The basic thing you must ensure is that the mattress fits properly into the crib. There should not be any gaps which could be risky for the baby. The mattress should also stay firmly in place. A soft one could take the shape of the face or head of the baby. This could enhance suffocation risks and it might also lead to SIDS or Sudden Infant Death Syndrome.

Types Of Crib Mattresses

When we talk about cribs there are basically two variants, innerspring and foam. As far as quality and durability are concerned, both are good. They are known to provide the best of support to babies and will remain in good shape for a long period of time. However, there is some difference as far as the material is concerned.

Foam mattresses are made from polyurethane. They are also lighter in weight and would weigh around 5 to 13 pounds. On the other hand when we talk about innerspring mattress they are much heavier and weigh between 15 to 30 pounds. The suitability would depend on specific comfort levels but generally it has been found that foam mattresses are easier to handle because of weight. They are also not as springy as spring mattresses. When the baby grows it is possible to use foam mattresses as trampoline.

However, innerspring are used even today in U.S mainly because adults continue to sleep on them and the habit has moved to the babies too.


There is no doubt that cost is an important factor when it comes to any product and crib mattresses are also no exception. Depending on quality, sizes, colors, designs and other attributes, one can buy a crib between $100 and $250. On the other hand if you are looking at innerspring mattresses or better quality foam ones, you may have to pay upwards $400. However, it would be wrong to judge a book by its cover. In the same light, when you are buying a crib mattress you should not decide based on the cover but find out what lies beneath it.

How To Choose The Right Crib Mattresses

As mentioned earlier, there are available in different qualities. The main variants are innerspring and foam ones. When buying innerspring mattresses you must have a look at the number of layers and also find out as to what each layer is made of. The quality of covering should also be taken into account.

Checking these attributes are important because they help a lot in increasing the comfort level of the mattresses.
When you are buying a foam mattress, you would be sure that they are made from polyurethane as the base materials. However, you must be sure that the foam is waterproof and optimally should weigh around 8 pounds and the price round be around $70 for a standard and value-for-money product.

The firmness of the foam should also be taken into account. It must be slightly on the heavy side and must be as resilient as possible. In other words, when the baby is taken out from the mattresses, it must come back to its original shape. Additionally, foam density is also something which must not be lost sight of. It may not be possible to check on the density in a brick and mortar stores. Hence you would be advised to check on the same online, make up your mind reasonably well and then move ahead and purchase it.

A Few More Points To Keep In Mind

Apart from the above, there are other important points which also must be taken into account. These include the border roads. When you are buying innerspring mattresses, if it does not have border rods, it would be better to stay away from it. They help a lot in making the product durable, provide firmness and also provide edge and side support. It will not sage when the baby walks or stands on the edge. Further, when you are going in innerspring variants, you must always look for the ones with more number of layers.

There are other factors such as steel gauge and coil count and these are basically applicable to only innerspring mattresses. There should be the right combination between steel gauge and coil count and this can be understood only when you have the right knowledge about it. It would be better to look for a steel gauge of 15.5 at the highest level and the coil count should also be in the range of 135 to 150.

Top 7 Crib Mattress Reviews

1. Newton Crib Mattress-A Breathable Crib Mattress

Newton Crib Mattress is one of the top crib mattresses for your baby are generally supportive and SIDS approved. It is specially designed for both crib and toddler bed to fit the proper healthy lifestyle of your baby. With so many amazing features in it, you will simply fall in love with this product. It is highly recommended for a good health of your baby. It is free from all toxin materials as well as free from latex, foam, glue and springs. It is very much comfortable for the newborn as well as for the toddlers. It is a perfect choice for your precious little one.

What We Love:

  • Made in USA
  • Greenguard certified
  • It is completely breathable
  • 100 % washable in machine or hand
  • You can even recycle this product (eco-friendly)
  • This is recommended by the doctors

What We Don’t Love:

  • Can not be shipped to Alaska or Hawaii

2. Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams – Waterproof Crib Mattress (Best Selling Crib Mattress Under $60)

Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams is the cheapest crib mattress on the market. It is always better to look for the safety when you are buying something for your precious baby. This Safety 1st heavenly Dreams mattress has achieved the GREENGUARD GOLD certification. This means that the product is eco-friendly and safe to be used. This crib mattress looks soft and is white in color. It is an imported product with a length of 52.5 inches,width of 27.2 inches and height of 5.5 inches. The thickness of this product is about 5.5 inches. The outer cover is made with vinyl and laminated with Polypropylene.

What We Love:

  • Best-selling cheapest crib mattress (Under $60 )
  • It is hypoallergenic
  • Greenguard Gold Certified
  • Lightweight, waterproof and comfortable
  • Perfect firm mattress for newborns
  • The product is extremely durable which will last for a long period of time

Keep in mind

  • You need to make sure that the length and width of the product is ideal for the crib of the baby. Also, make sure to use a cover over this so that you can wash it off regularly.

3. Naturepedic No Compromise – GOTS Certified Best Organic Crib Mattress

Naturepedic No Compromise is a GOTS certified best organic crib mattress which is really good for the baby. It is an award winning mattress within no toxins and only healthy materials. It is totally U.S based organic cotton filled mattress which meets the food contact standard. There is no vinyl, PVC, lead or phthalates in it. Even it does not contain any harmful chemical which can affect the health of the baby. It is made under the rules and regulations of USA so that it can fit into all the standard cribs made inUSA. The size and shape is perfect according to the US standards.

What We Love:

  • It’s a GOTS certified organic crib mattress (no toxins)
  • This is a dual firmness crib mattress
  • 100 % waterproof surface which is very easy to clean with a damp sponge
  • No potential high allergy materials like latex, wool or coir
  • Replacement any time
  • Great Customer Support

Keep in mind

  • The dimension of the crib mattress is 6 x 27.8 x 52 inches which is perfect for the toddler bed or cribs.

4. Sealy Soybean Foam Core – Best Natural Foam Crib Mattress

Sealy Soybean Foam-core is the top rated crib mattress available on Amazon. This is another great foam crib mattress which is made up of foams. The designs and patterns may vary from one mattress to another but the size should be perfect according to your baby’s crib. This is an award winning USA made crib mattress which is voted as the most popular brand. In the recent years, this has emerged as the most reliable and trusted brand of the mothers for their babies. The whole mattress is covered properly with neat stitching.

What We Love:

  • Made in USA
  • Greenguard certified
  • Award winning crib mattress
  • Perfect firm mattress for newborn
  • It’s very lightweight, sturdy and good quality
  • It is completely waterproof as well as stain-resistant and thus it is easy to clean
  • Crib mattress is made up of soybean oils which is great for healthy sleeping for your baby.

Keep in mind

  • The corners of this crib mattress is square is shape which is perfect for the snug fit with the crib walls. So, choose the right width and length.

5. Colgote Classica III – Dual Firm Crib Mattress

Colgate Eco Classica is made in such a shape and size that will fit into all the cribs made in American standard size. This mattress is made in United States of America (USA). It is a great mattress which is soft and comfortable. The baby can get a complete and comfortable sleep on this mattress without any problem. The best part of this mattress is its fittings which emits the danger of gap between mattress and cribs. That is why for all the American cribs it is best to opt for a mattress which is made in USA like this.

What We Love:

  • Made in USA
  • GREENGUARD certified there is no harmful emission
  • Dual firmness with 6 inches thickness
  • Made up of comfortable and relaxing memory foam
  • Waterproof and PVC free
  • It is completely waterproof as well as eco-friendly in nature which is best for the baby
  • Super lightweight baby mattress

Keep in mind

  • This is memory foam which automatically adjusts with the body temperature of the baby. The foam is 100 % safe with CertiPUR-US certification.

6. Moonlight Sunlight Little Dreamer – Perfect Firmness for Both an Infant And a Toddler

If you are looking for a healthy and eco friendly crib mattress for your baby which is firm yet comfortable, then this is the one. It is one of the most popular choices in Amazon Ebaby Special products. It is completely free from dangerous substances like PVC, polyethylene, lead and phthalates. This mattress is 100 % waterproof and resistant to stains. The high density foam helps in providing the best support to the baby while he/she is sleeping.

What We Love:

  • Made in USA
  • GREENGUARD certified
  • Dual Firmness Mattress
  • It is highly durable and will last for long time
  • The mattress is void of any toxic materials
  • Since it is waterproof there is no chance of sweat or water to get absorbed within
  • It is treated with antimicrobial protection which provides great freshness.
  • No chemical smell
  • Firmer side for infants and softer side for toddler

Keep in mind

You can easily clean the mattress with the help of a damp sponge in case there is any dust and dirt. Since the mattress is waterproof you do not have to worry.

7. My First Mattress Memory Foam – Super Comfortable for Infants and Toddler

My First Mattress Memory Foam is another great crib mattress for Infants and Toddler. The memory foams are comfortable and firm with a lot of advantages. The best thing about them is that they can adjust according to different shapes of bodies as well as the temperature of the body. Thus it is ideal for the babies as they need the best and completely uninterrupted sleep. This will help them in growth and development. The good thing is that the cover is completely washable. Hence, you can wash for a better safety of health.

What We Love:

  • It is certified by CertiPUR-US for the best quality flexible polyurethane foam
  • It is made up of extra firm high-density foam that can support the babies
  • It is super comfortable for the baby to get the best sleep
  • The mattress is hypoallergenic and mite proof for better safety of the baby
  • It has qualified in the flammability test
  • The cover of the mattress is completely waterproof in nature

Keep in mind

  • Wash the cover often to make sure there are no dusts and impurities which is likely to have after daily use.